A tale of errors
Contrary to the claims of the UIDAI, fingerprints are a highly inappropriate tool to uniquely identify individuals.
Read at: http://www.flonnet.com/fl2913/stories/20120713291303400.htm
Contrary to the claims of the UIDAI, fingerprints are a highly inappropriate tool to uniquely identify individuals.
"The CPI(M) does not share the EPW editorial view that all non-Congress, non-BJP parties are merely “right-wing, regional, caste-based outfits”, who do not have any democratic potential. Such an ahistorical and holier-than-thou attitude would only isolate the left in national politics and aid the polarisation of the Indian polity into Congress- and BJP-led camps, which is so desperately desired by the ruling classes...Left tactics have to be shaped on the basis of ground realities and not wishful thinking.
The EPW edit berates the CPI (M)-led government in West Bengal for crushing “peasant resistance to the grabbing of their land” in Nandigram. The CPI (M) has repeatedly regretted the police firing in 2007, which led to tragic deaths. It needs to be reiterated, however, that not an inch of land was actually acquired in Nandigram. To argue that the CPI (M) has lost its credibility forever on that account is odd and rancorous.
EPW seems to be oblivious of the significant peasant struggles being waged by the All India Kisan Sabha since 2007 against forcible land acquisition across several states like Andhra Pradesh, Uttar Pradesh, Haryana, Odhisha and Madhya Pradesh. CPI (M) has also been actively participating in the anti-land acquisition struggle against the Jaitapur nuclear power project in Maharashtra. The DPR unambiguously states: “The Party and the kisan and agricultural labour organisations should take the lead to fight for the rights of the peasants on land and to oppose any forcible land acquisition” (Para 2.27). The DPR has also adopted a strong stand against the provisions of the proposed Land Acquisition and Rehabilitation Bill which seeks to facilitate land grab under the cover of addressing farmers’ concerns (Paras 2.28 and 2.29).
Besides, the Kisan Sabha is taking up other agrarian issues like lack of fair prices, subsidy cuts in fertilisers, hike in power tariffs, etc. There was a day-long agriculture strike in West Bengal in early January 2012 sponsored by left-wing peasant organisations against the crash of paddy and potato prices. Over 30 farmers have committed suicide in West Bengal since the TMC-led government has come to power in May 2011, because the crop procurement machinery has collapsed in the state. The debate on agrarian issues needs to move beyond Nandigram and focus on the current plight of the peasantry in West Bengal and elsewhere."
“…to pin the blame on the principle of democratic centralism, which, going by AM’s explanation, has led to an inevitable degeneration in the CPI(M), is confusing. If one accepts this as the basic flaw within the CPI(M), then the task of rectification should start by abandoning democratic centralism. The evidence across the world, especially in the European countries, clearly show that abandoning democratic centralism far from leading to any rejuvenation of the communist left in the post-Soviet Union period, has led to their ideological disarray and organisational decimation. This is because democratic centralism as a concept is central to the functioning of a communist party, arising out of the necessity to have an organised and disciplined structure, which can take on the organised might of the bourgeois state apparatus. This necessity does not arise only during a revolutionary situation, but remains generally valid because of the very nature and power of the bourgeois state, which is ever keen to weaken class struggle and snuff out the communists.
… abandoning democratic centralism, far from aiding the rectification effort will only derail any attempt at course correction.”
“...should not be seen in isolation from the overall strategic tie-up with the United States. The nuclear cooperation deal is an integral part of the July 2005 joint statement, which has political, economic and strategic aspects. It is also closely linked to the June 2005 military framework agreement signed with the United States. It is therefore not possible to view the text of the bilateral “123” agreement negotiated with the United States as a separate and compartmentalised entity without considering its implications for India’s independent foreign policy, strategic autonomy and the repercussions of the US quest to make India its reliable ally in Asia...”.
“The two reactors set-up in Koodankulam and purchased from Russia much before the nuclear deal falls in a different category. The local people have various apprehensions about the safety and the impact on the environment of these reactors, especially after the Fukushima accident. It is necessary to conduct an independent safety review and allay the apprehensions of the people before commissioning the plant. The CPI(M) has demanded an immediate halt to the import of nuclear power plants to Jaitapur and other locations. Existing nuclear power plants in India should undergo a thorough safety review to be conducted by an independent body. There has to be an independent and autonomous nuclear safety regulatory authority. The proposed legislation by the government to set up such an authority will only make it a controlled body captive to the government.”
“The State Committee of the Communist Party of India (Marxist) on Wednesday urged Central and State governments to initiate steps for commencing operations of the Koodankulam project soon after reviewing the reports submitted by the expert committees.”
“The State unit of the Communist Party of India (Marxist) on Friday called upon anti-Koodankulam Nuclear Power Project (KKNPP) protestors to give up their agitation, as panels of experts appointed by the Centre and the State governments had vouched for the safety of the plants...In a statement here, State secretary of the party G. Ramakrishnan welcomed the State government decision to go ahead with the commissioning of the plants. He requested the local people to extend their support for the functioning of the plants.”
“The State unit of the Communist Party of India (Marxist) has urged the Centre to defer the generation of power from Koodankulam Nuclear Power Project until all its safety aspects are ensured. In a statement here, CPI (M) secretary G. Ramakrishnan said that after the accident in a Japanese atomic power plant following tsunami, a fear psychosis had cropped up all over the world regarding atomic power stations. This had triggered a fast at Koodankulam in which a number of local people and organisations were involved.
While a number of countries were subjecting their atomic power plants to re-certification, India was also trying to get such a certification for the new nuclear reactor it was planning to buy from France. “However, as far as the Koodankulam plant is concerned, only a superficial inspection was conducted after the incident in the Japanese plant. It is not satisfactory,” he said.
The CPI (M) pleaded that a “trustworthy team” of experts should certify the safety aspects of the Koodankulam plant. Besides, both the Atomic Energy Commission and Nuclear Power Corporation should set up all the safety measures. “In addition, this atomic power plant should be brought under the Nuclear Liability Bill”.
“Also, the government should convince the public that their livelihood will not be affected because of the plant. Till these things are completed, commencement of power generation should be deferred”, he said.”
“On the Koodankulam Nuclear Power Project, Mr. Ramakrishnan said that the people in Tirunelveli district still entertained fears about the safety of the project. He, therefore, wanted the government to keep the project in abeyance till an independent committee of experts studied the project and guaranteed its safety.”
“The Centre should put on hold all works at the Koodankulam Nuclear Power Project till an independent expert committee certified the safety of the nuclear reactors there, the Communist Party of India (Marxist) secretary, G. Ramakrishnan, has said. Talking to reporters here on Friday, he said that though the type of reactors used in Koodankulam were in use in European countries for the last four decades, it was for the first time that this type of reactor was being installed in India. Pointing to the apprehension expressed by the local people, Mr. Ramakrishnan said that the Centre should appoint an independent expert committee to study the safety aspects of the reactors. “Till such time the panel certifies the safety of the reactors, the work should be put on hold,” he said. The Centre should handle the issue in the right way, he added.”
“On the Koodankulam Nuclear Power Plant row, he said that the priority of the government should be to allay the fears of the local people on the safety of the plant. The Centre should also consider developing livelihood infrastructure for the local people as suggested by the former President, A.P.J. Abdul Kalam, he added.”
“In a release, CPI (M) general secretary G. Ramakrishnan stated that based on former President A.P.J. Abdul Kalam’s recommendations, the Centre should ensure the safety of those in and around Koodankulam and allocate Rs.200 crore for development activities.”
“The CPI(M) condemns the police repression on the people protesting against the commissioning of the nuclear power plant at Koodankulam. Those arrested are being charged with sedition and for waging war against the State which is baseless and unwarranted. There are reports of water supply being cut off and other essential supplies being blocked to the Idinthakari village. The CPI(M) calls upon the state administration not to resort to repression and force against peaceful protesters. Since there are a number of issues still agitating the people regarding the nuclear plant, the concerned authorities should immediately begin talks to address these issues.”
“In a statement, State secretary of the party G. Ramakrishnan welcomed the State government decision to go ahead with the commissioning of the plants. He requested the local people to extend their support for the functioning of the plants. Mr. Ramakrishnan said that instead of resorting to repressive measures such as filing criminal cases against the protestors, the State government should take steps to allay the fears of people about the technology and safety aspects of the Koodankulam project.”
“CPM state secretary G Ramakrishnan on Friday urged the state government to make efforts to muster support for the Koodankulam nuclear power project by convincing the anti-nuclear protesters on the safety aspects.”
“Mr. Ramakrishnan said that instead of resorting to repressive measures such as filing criminal cases against the protestors, the State government should take steps to allay the fears of people about the technology and safety aspects of the Koodankulam project.”
CPI (M) demonstration demanding withdrawal of cases on people of Idinthakarai: 100 persons including MLA Nagai Mali, arrested
Tirunelveli, dated May 18th 2012
The CPI (M) carried out a demonstration demanding the withdrawal of cases instituted by the Government of Tamil Nadu against the people opposing the Koodankulam nuclear plant. Hundreds of people who participated in the demonstration, including MLA Nagai Mali, were arrested.
The Secretary of the Tirunelveli Corporation unit of the CPI (M) R. Karunanidhi presided over the demonstration and meeting, which took place in Jawahar Maidan in Palayankottai.
The CPI (M) district secretary spoke inaugurating the demonstration. Former MLA Noor Mohammed and Nagai Mali MLA spoke condemning the launching of cases. The CPI (M) district secretariat member V. Palani, other District Secretariat members, corporation committee members, District Committee members and many others participated. Since there was no police permission for the demonstration, the police arrested hundreds of people who took part in the demonstration. They were released a few hours later.
|A photo of the demonstration organised by the CPI (M) at Jawahar Maidan in Palayankottai dated 18th May 2012 against police repression on agitating people at Idinthakarai.|
From another news report on the same speech in Tamil:
"காங்கிரஸ் ஊழல் கறைபிடிந்த கட்சி, பிஜேபி மதவெறி கட்சி, இந்தியாவில் உழைக்கும் மக்களுக்காக குமரி முதல் இமயம் வியாபித்து போராடும் இயக்கம் மார்க்சிஸ்ட் கட்சி என போராட்டக்குழுவின் அமைப்பாளர் உதயகுமார் வரவேற்று பேசினார்."
“On May 18, 2012, a Communist Party of India (Marxist) team came to visit us at Idinthakarai under the leadership of Comrade P. Mahalingam (aka V.P. Nagai Maali), an MLA from Kilvelur constituency in Tamil Nadu. That evening the CPI(M) organized an agitation at Tirunelveli in support of us and some 50 of them including 6 women were arrested by police.”